Coinbase Said New York Attorney General Asked SEC to Declare Ethereum a Security: Report
By: finance magnates|2025/05/08 04:30:01
0
Share
Coinbase released internal U.S. Securities andExchange Commission communications showing that New York's top law enforcementoffice urged the agency to classify Ethereum’s ether (ETH) as a security duringits legal pursuit of crypto exchange KuCoin in 2023. The request, reportedly made by the New York AttorneyGeneral's office, adds another layer to the ongoing debate over digital assetclassifications and the federal agencies responsible for them. NY Wanted SEC to File Statement Supporting ETHSecurity Designation According to Coindesk, the communication came fromShamiso Maswoswe, head of the New York Attorney General’s Investor ProtectionBureau, who explicitly asked the SEC to weigh in on Ethereum’s legal status insupport of the state’s case. Maswoswe noted that while the classification wouldn’tdetermine the case's outcome, since the state has jurisdiction over bothsecurities and commodities, it would help “get a court to hold that Ether is asecurity,” which she argued would enhance investor protection. The SEC, however, remained silent. It had previouslyhinted at Ethereum’s commodity status but became more ambiguous after Ethereumtransitioned to proof-of-stake. Ultimately, the agency refrained from filingany statement on ETH's status in the KuCoin matter. Coinbase released the document as part of a widereffort to make public the communications it has obtained through Freedom ofInformation Act requests. These materials include emails and internal notesthat reveal how federal regulators have handled, or avoided, key decisions oncrypto asset classifications. Regulatory Tensions This latest batch includes messages not only aboutEthereum, but also about Ripple and XRP. In one 2021 email, SEC staff debatedwhether Ripple’s blockchain was decentralized. The SEC was even ordered to return a portion of thepenalties it had previously collected. The friction between NewYork’s request and the SEC’s muted response highlights broader jurisdictionalconfusion at the federal level. While New York's Department of Financial Servicesoversees both securities and commodities, federal regulation remains dividedbetween the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), withoverlapping and often conflicting mandates. New York’s enforcement action against KuCoin concludedin December 2023, with a $22 million settlement. The state alleged the exchangefailed to register to operate legally. Since President Donald Trump returned to office, hisadministration has signaled a friendlier stance toward digital assets. Hisappointment of Paul Atkins as SEC chairman has already prompted the agency tobegin clarifying which parts of the crypto sector it does not consider underits purview. Coinbase released internal U.S. Securities andExchange Commission communications showing that New York's top law enforcementoffice urged the agency to classify Ethereum’s ether (ETH) as a security duringits legal pursuit of crypto exchange KuCoin in 2023. The request, reportedly made by the New York AttorneyGeneral's office, adds another layer to the ongoing debate over digital assetclassifications and the federal agencies responsible for them. NY Wanted SEC to File Statement Supporting ETHSecurity Designation According to Coindesk, the communication came fromShamiso Maswoswe, head of the New York Attorney General’s Investor ProtectionBureau, who explicitly asked the SEC to weigh in on Ethereum’s legal status insupport of the state’s case. Maswoswe noted that while the classification wouldn’tdetermine the case's outcome, since the state has jurisdiction over bothsecurities and commodities, it would help “get a court to hold that Ether is asecurity,” which she argued would enhance investor protection. The SEC, however, remained silent. It had previouslyhinted at Ethereum’s commodity status but became more ambiguous after Ethereumtransitioned to proof-of-stake. Ultimately, the agency refrained from filingany statement on ETH's status in the KuCoin matter. Coinbase released the document as part of a widereffort to make public the communications it has obtained through Freedom ofInformation Act requests. These materials include emails and internal notesthat reveal how federal regulators have handled, or avoided, key decisions oncrypto asset classifications. Regulatory Tensions This latest batch includes messages not only aboutEthereum, but also about Ripple and XRP. In one 2021 email, SEC staff debatedwhether Ripple’s blockchain was decentralized. The SEC was even ordered to return a portion of thepenalties it had previously collected. The friction between NewYork’s request and the SEC’s muted response highlights broader jurisdictionalconfusion at the federal level. While New York's Department of Financial Servicesoversees both securities and commodities, federal regulation remains dividedbetween the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), withoverlapping and often conflicting mandates. New York’s enforcement action against KuCoin concludedin December 2023, with a $22 million settlement. The state alleged the exchangefailed to register to operate legally. Since President Donald Trump returned to office, hisadministration has signaled a friendlier stance toward digital assets. Hisappointment of Paul Atkins as SEC chairman has already prompted the agency tobegin clarifying which parts of the crypto sector it does not consider underits purview.
You may also like

Particle Founder: The entrepreneurial insights I have gained the most from in the past year
Stop lean startup, stop lightning entrepreneurship, and think carefully about what your product aspirations are.

Huang Renxun's latest podcast transcript: The future of Nvidia, the development of embodied intelligence and agents, the explosion of inference demand, and the public relations crisis of artificial intelligence
The competition in the future is not just about whose model is larger or whose computing power is stronger, but also about who understands the industry better, who can embed AI more deeply into real processes, and who can organize these capabilities into a runnable and scalable system.

OKX Ventures Research Report: AI Agent Economic Infrastructure Research Report (Part 1)
The existing infrastructure is hostile to the Agent economy. Agents can think and act independently at the "capability level," but at the "economic level," they are still locked into infrastructure designed for humans.

The migration of settlement rights: B18 and the institutional starting point of on-chain banks
In the traditional system, banks decide the settlement; in the on-chain system, code begins to take over this responsibility.

From Tencent and Circle: Looking at the Simple and Difficult Questions of Investment
The AI narrative continues to ferment, but the recent performance of related stocks varies, with some in the midst of summer and others as if in winter.

The second half of stablecoins no longer belongs to the crypto circle
What Coinbase doesn't want, Mastercard is eager to buy.

Cursor "Shell" Kimi Controversy Reversed: From Copyright Infringement Allegations to Authorized Collaboration, China's Open Source Model Once Again Becomes a Global AI Foundation
Cursor was accused of being based on Kimi K2.5, which sparked controversy, and was later confirmed to be compliant through Fireworks AI due diligence.

The Real Reason Tokens Don't Sell: 90% of Crypto Projects Overlook Investor Relations
Provide an Investor Relations Best Practices Guide for Crypto Projects.

Is the income of pump.fun real, earning a million dollars a day despite the market downturn?
If it can really earn this much, what is the reason for the low price of $PUMP?

The real reason why tokens are not selling: 90% of crypto projects neglect investor relations
Investor Relations Practice Guide for Cryptocurrency Projects.

Who is the true winner of the "Tokenization" narrative?
Virtually everyone benefits, but the reason for the benefit, the timing, and the underlying logic are completely different.

Moss: The Era of AI-Traded by Anyone | Project Introduction
AI Trading Agent is rapidly growing its infrastructure.

Chip Smuggling Case Exposes Regulatory Loophole | Rewire News Evening Update
AI chips have become a strategic asset more sensitive than missiles

How a Structured AI Crypto Trading Bot Won at the WEEX Hackathon
Ritmex demonstrates how disciplined risk control and structured signals can make an AI crypto trading bot more stable and reliable on WEEX, highlighting the importance of combining execution discipline with scalable AI trading systems.

Old Indicator Fails, Three Major New Signals Emerge: BTC True Bottom May Still Be Below $60K
When the grocery shopping auntie on the subway, or Tony the hairdresser, start asking you about BTC, crypto, and cryptocurrency investments, selling immediately will be the only best option.

Meeting OpenClaw Founder at a Hackathon: What Else Can Lobsters Do?
Imperial College London MetaGame: AI Agent × Web3 Landing Three Major Directions.

Huang Renxun's Latest Podcast Transcript: NVIDIA's Future, Embodied Intelligence and Agent Development, Soaring Demand for Inferencing, and AI's PR Crisis
The future of competition is not only about whose model is bigger, whose computing power is stronger, but also about who understands the industry better, who can more deeply integrate AI into real processes, and who can organize these capabilities into a set of executable, scalable systems
How a Structured AI Crypto Trading Bot Won at the WEEX Hackathon
Crypto_Trade shows how structured inputs and controlled adaptability can build a more stable and reliable AI crypto trading bot within the WEEX AI Trading Hackathon, highlighting a practical path toward scalable AI trading systems.
Particle Founder: The entrepreneurial insights I have gained the most from in the past year
Stop lean startup, stop lightning entrepreneurship, and think carefully about what your product aspirations are.
Huang Renxun's latest podcast transcript: The future of Nvidia, the development of embodied intelligence and agents, the explosion of inference demand, and the public relations crisis of artificial intelligence
The competition in the future is not just about whose model is larger or whose computing power is stronger, but also about who understands the industry better, who can embed AI more deeply into real processes, and who can organize these capabilities into a runnable and scalable system.
OKX Ventures Research Report: AI Agent Economic Infrastructure Research Report (Part 1)
The existing infrastructure is hostile to the Agent economy. Agents can think and act independently at the "capability level," but at the "economic level," they are still locked into infrastructure designed for humans.
The migration of settlement rights: B18 and the institutional starting point of on-chain banks
In the traditional system, banks decide the settlement; in the on-chain system, code begins to take over this responsibility.
From Tencent and Circle: Looking at the Simple and Difficult Questions of Investment
The AI narrative continues to ferment, but the recent performance of related stocks varies, with some in the midst of summer and others as if in winter.
The second half of stablecoins no longer belongs to the crypto circle
What Coinbase doesn't want, Mastercard is eager to buy.