Supreme Court Equates Bitcoin Trading to Modern Hawala Network
By: live bitcoin news|2025/05/07 10:15:02
0
Share
Supreme Court Sees Bitcoin HawalaJustices admit limited understanding of Bitcoin technology.According to India’s highest court, Trading Bitcoin is similar to using the illicit Hawala money transfer system. Shailesh Babulal Bhatt is being accused of engaging in illegal trading of Bitcoin, as mentioned at the bail hearing.One of the most significant concerns that the court had was the absence of cryptocurrency regulation in India. Absent clear guidelines, Justices said, we are in a vacuum where illicit financial activity is not only possible, but possible on a huge scale. The bench also specifically pointed out that Bitcoin trading in its unregulated state is not much different from Hawala, a traditional method of carrying out illegal money transfers.The bench was led by Justice Surya Kant, who also admitted having limited knowledge of Bitcoin. During the hearing, he said, “I don’t fully grasp the intricacies of Bitcoin technology.” However, he highlighted that the unregulated nature of cryptocurrency makes it susceptible to usage like that of a sophisticated variant of Hawala.This came as part of a wider debate on the need for a strong legal framework for digital currencies. Earlier, more than two years ago, the bench had reminded the central government of its demand to clarify its stand on cryptocurrency regulation. But no significant response has been given to date, and the judiciary and public remain in the dark.Regulatory Delays Under ScrutinyThe central government was criticized by the Supreme Court for inaction. The bench added that a proper regulatory regime could provide a way to combat the risks of Bitcoin trading. Justice Kant said this is a polished form of Hawala business and there is an urgent need for clarity in this regard.During the court, Rohatgi, who was defending Bhatt, said that the trade of Bitcoins is not against the law in India and that Bitcoins are not considered to be tangible versions of cash. Referring to a previous Supreme Court decision that overturned an RBI circular forbidding cryptocurrency transactions, he said. However, the bench was adamant that a defined legal structure be set up to prevent misuse.The Gujarat government and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) have been given 10 days to respond to the matter by the court. Further discussions on Bhatt’s bail and the matter of cryptocurrency regulation are expected to take place at the next hearing on May 19, 2025.The legal status of cryptocurrencies in India has become a hotbed once again. The government has implemented taxation and anti-money laundering (AML) for digital assets, but has not yet established a comprehensive regulatory framework. The Supreme Court’s comparison to Hawala calls out the alarm bells that cryptos can be misused for illegal financial activities.The Broader Implications and Urgent Need for Crypto Education in IndiaThe Supreme Court’s recent observations on India’s approach to digital currencies identify a critical gap. Bitcoin is the world’s largest cryptocurrency that is run on a decentralized blockchain network, and so it is nearly impossible to track the transactions unless closely supervised. A key feature of anonymity, but also criticized for hiding illicit activities, as the court also points out.For context, Hawala is an informal money transfer system that has no traditional banking channels. It has previously been the target of hard-line enforcement by authorities for use in money laundering or to fund terrorism. According to the court, Bitcoin is comparable to the money that it is compared to, and if it were to be left uncontrolled, it may be just as hazardous as the cash in question.Justice Kant also admits that there is another problem in this connection, that judicial authorities do not understand this problem. However, many Indian authorities and officials lack a thorough understanding of the technical features of cryptocurrencies, which would make it difficult to effectively regulate them. Because of a lack of knowledge, policies may be too restrictive or provide inadequate protections in this area.This implies that more education has to be done to the public and the government,s especially now that the Supreme Court has openly admitted that it still has lots to learn about cryptocurrencies. In order to develop balanced regulations, which would ensure the safety of consumers and promote the use of this technology alongside the creation of applications based on it, familiarizing oneself with the possibilities that blockchain technology offers is an essential practice.The post Supreme Court Equates Bitcoin Trading to Modern Hawala Network appeared first on Live Bitcoin News.
You may also like

Memories: 10 Key Contributions of the TON Core Team That Few People Knew in the Early Days
Every line of code, every tool we build, every sleepless night spent maintaining the network—these efforts have laid the foundation for TON's development today.

2025 South Korea CEX Listing Post-Mortem: Investing in New Coins = 70% Loss?
The 2025 South Korean exchange's new token listing performance is structurally similar to Binance's, with no significant differences.

BIP-360 Analysis: Bitcoin's First Step Towards Quantum Immunity, But Why Only the "First Step"?
This article explains how BIP-360 reshapes Bitcoin's quantum defense strategy, analyzes its enhancements, and discusses why it has not yet achieved full post-quantum security.

50 million USDT exchanged for 35,000 USD AAVE: How did the disaster happen? Who should we blame?
Due to a fatal flaw in the transaction path, a $50 million DeFi operation was executed with almost zero protection, resulting in nearly the entire amount of funds evaporating in a tiny liquidity pool.

The Cryptographic Past of the Middle East
Reality is often more exciting than fiction.

Resolving the Intergenerational Prisoner's Dilemma: The Inevitable Path of Nomadic Capital Bitcoin
When the baby boomer generation collectively sells off, who will become the "greater fool" in the next round of asset crashes?

Who Will Control AI? Why Decentralized AI May Be the Only Alternative to Government and Big Tech
AI has become critical infrastructure, and governments and corporations are competing to control it. Centralized development and regulation are entrenching existing power structures. The Web3 community is building a decentralized alternative — distributed compute, token incentives, and community governance — before that window closes.

Vitalik wrote a proposal teaching you how to secretly use AI large models
Vitalik believes that in the AI era, users should not have to give up their identity to use an AI tool.

On the eve of the explosion of on-chain options
Options are becoming a new anchor in the cryptocurrency market.

WEEX AI Hackathon: How Did This AI Trading Winner Succeed?
A self-taught AI trading enthusiast achieved top-10 results at the WEEX AI Hackathon. Learn about the mindset, AI tools, and lessons behind this impressive performance.

One Balance to Rule Them All: Gravitas' On-Chain Prime Broker Ambition
Forty years ago, a technological revolution broke the isolation of information, reshaping Wall Street. Forty years later, Grvt aims to break the isolation of capital with an on-chain prime brokerage model.

That person who cashed out at the NFT peak is now selling a new shovel in the OpenClaw craze
A skilled person never picks the table, they eat meat with every bite.

Inter-generational Prisoner's Dilemma Resolution: The Nomadic Capital and Bitcoin's Inevitable Path
When the Baby Boomer generation collectively sells off, who will be the "bag holder" in the next asset crash?

Upstream and downstream are starting to fight, all for the sake of everyone being able to "Lobster"
「Lobster」 may not be a mature product yet, but it has already ushered in a new era of 「AI Assistants」.

Circle and Mastercard Announce Partnership, the Next Stage for the Crypto Industry Belongs to Payments
Stablecoins are transitioning from a speculative tool to real financial scenarios such as payments, cross-border transfers, and store of value.

From 5 Mao per kWh of Chinese electricity to a $45 API export: Tokens are rewriting currency units
When the same unit can both measure hashing power and facilitate payments, it ceases to be just a term and begins to evolve into a new currency of both value and influence.

Why is OpenAI playing catch-up to Claude Code instead?
Anthropic Bets Earlier on AI Programming, OpenAI Strategic Tempo Misaligned

Vitalik wrote a proposal teaching you how to secretly use AI large models
Vitalik believes that in the AI era, users should not have to sacrifice their identity to use an AI tool.
Memories: 10 Key Contributions of the TON Core Team That Few People Knew in the Early Days
Every line of code, every tool we build, every sleepless night spent maintaining the network—these efforts have laid the foundation for TON's development today.
2025 South Korea CEX Listing Post-Mortem: Investing in New Coins = 70% Loss?
The 2025 South Korean exchange's new token listing performance is structurally similar to Binance's, with no significant differences.
BIP-360 Analysis: Bitcoin's First Step Towards Quantum Immunity, But Why Only the "First Step"?
This article explains how BIP-360 reshapes Bitcoin's quantum defense strategy, analyzes its enhancements, and discusses why it has not yet achieved full post-quantum security.
50 million USDT exchanged for 35,000 USD AAVE: How did the disaster happen? Who should we blame?
Due to a fatal flaw in the transaction path, a $50 million DeFi operation was executed with almost zero protection, resulting in nearly the entire amount of funds evaporating in a tiny liquidity pool.
The Cryptographic Past of the Middle East
Reality is often more exciting than fiction.
Resolving the Intergenerational Prisoner's Dilemma: The Inevitable Path of Nomadic Capital Bitcoin
When the baby boomer generation collectively sells off, who will become the "greater fool" in the next round of asset crashes?