25 million stolen in 12 seconds: the MEV brothers acquitted

By: journalducoin.com|11/17/2026 06:30:00

Two rooms, two atmospheres, one court. On Monday, November 16, the federal court in Manhattan issued two rulings that each define where the criminal line lies in crypto. On one side, Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT graduates accused of siphoning 25 million dollars from Ethereum bots in twelve seconds. On the other side, a former Robinhood engineer pleaded guilty to 125,523 dollars in gains on Hyperliquid. The amount seems trivial compared to the wallet heist punished with 17 years in prison last week.

Key points of this article:

  • The judge believes the prosecution failed to prove any false statements and that the transactions did not occur on a regulated market.
  • Huaisong Xiang admits to having traded perpetuals before at least 11 Robinhood listing announcements and returns his profits.
  • In both cases, the judge seeks a lie directed at a person, not a trick played against a machine.

Peraire-Bueno Brothers: the MEV exploit of 25 million is not electronic fraud

Back to April 2023. The two brothers set up sixteen validators on Ethereum and wait for "sandwich" bots to bite. These robots spot a third-party transaction in the queue, position themselves before and after to cash in on the price difference, and rely on the MEV-Boost relay to avoid having their block betrayed. The Peraire-Bueno brothers exploit a flaw in this relay, replace the bait transaction with their own, and drain three bots of 25 million dollars. Duration of the operation: twelve seconds. Arrested in May 2024, charged with electronic fraud, conspiracy, and money laundering, facing up to 20 years per charge.

The first trial ended in November 2025 with a hung jury. Peter Van Valkenburgh from Coin Center then spoke of a "massive overreach" by the prosecution. On Monday, Judge Clarke ruled before even a second trial by granting the defense's acquittal request. Her reasoning boils down to two points. The question was not whether the strategy was "inappropriate or unethical," but whether it constituted electronic fraud, and the government never demonstrated a "materially false statement." The bots did not speak to anyone, nor did the brothers. Furthermore, these transactions did not take place on a regulated market where such maneuver would be prohibited.

An acquittal pronounced by the judge closes the door to a new trial. The case, which the Justice Department presented in 2024 as a world first, stops here. For validators and MEV seekers, the message is clear: on Ethereum, trapping a bot that traps others does not fall under federal fraud law, as long as no one lies to someone.

Robinhood and Hyperliquid: the insider who traded listings before everyone else

A few hours later, Huaisong "Jerry" Xiang, 30, pleaded guilty to a single count of electronic fraud before Judge Colleen McMahon. An engineer at Robinhood from around 2024 to September 2026, he was part of the "Coin Aware" employees, informed in a private Slack channel about the tokens that Robinhood Crypto would list. The internal rule prohibited them from trading these tokens before the announcement and for the following 24 hours. Xiang did the opposite at least eleven times between 2025 and 2026, with long positions in perpetuals on Hyperliquid: POPCAT in March 2025, then MEW, MOODENG, ONDO, or RENDER, opened before the listing and closed once the price moved.

The cumulative gain is trivial compared to the previous case, 125,523 dollars, which Xiang has agreed to return. His sentence will be set on February 25, 2027, with a theoretical maximum of 20 years. His colleague Hefu Chai, 36, indicted in September for at least ten similar operations, is not mentioned in the prosecution's announcement and remains presumed innocent. Robinhood stated it conducted an internal investigation and forwarded the case to the authorities.

The legal lesson applies to all those who believe a DEX offers protection. The prosecution did not have to classify POPCAT as a financial security nor Hyperliquid as an exchange. The fraud played out at the source, at Robinhood, where Xiang owed the secret to his employer. Prosecutor Jamie McDonald summarized it in one sentence: no matter the platform, an insider who trades on diverted information will be held accountable. The federal prosecutor's announcement from Manhattan (SDNY) regarding the charges against Huaisong Xiang and Hefu Chai on September 15, 2026. Source: Department of Justice

What these two verdicts change for crypto

Two cases, two outcomes, and one single framework for interpretation. American electronic fraud punishes the lie made to someone, not the skill against a machine. It catches the engineer who sells information from his employer, while it lets the brothers who read the code better than the bots slip away. The next heads of the SEC and CFTC will inherit a perpetual market where this distinction will set a precedent.

-- Price

--
--
--

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Any events, rewards, online promotions, or related information mentioned herein should not be considered a recommendation, solicitation, or invitation to purchase, sell, trade, or otherwise deal in any crypto assets. Crypto assets are highly volatile and may result in loss. The availability of WEEX services, products, and related events may vary by region. You are responsible for ensuring that your participation is in accordance with applicable local laws and regulations.

You may also like

iconiconiconiconiconiconiconiconicon
Customer Support:@weikecs
Business Cooperation:@weikecs
Quant Trading & MM:bd@weex.com
VIP Program:support@weex.com