Mathematicians Disheartened by OpenAI Are Now Building Their Own AI Models from Scratch

By: www.laohunote.com|

The conflict between the mathematics academic community and large AI companies is escalating. After OpenAI announced that it had used AI to tackle several mathematical problems, it not only failed to gain widespread recognition from the academic community but also sparked intense debates about the ownership of research results, data usage rights, and the value of AI in problem-solving. Some mathematicians believe that commercial companies are turning mathematical research results into products and marketing materials without adequately respecting the contributions and rights of the academic community.

In this context, an increasing number of mathematicians are attempting to bypass commercial AI companies by independently developing open-source models and research tools. Reports indicate that Professor Sergei Gukov from Caltech is leading a team to build AI models specifically for mathematical research; Fields Medal winner and UCLA professor Terence Tao is promoting the establishment of an AI collaboration platform controlled by mathematicians.

The focus of this debate has extended beyond whether AI can solve mathematical problems to who controls research data, how to evaluate AI-generated mathematical results, and whether the academic community can retain autonomy amid the rapid expansion of commercial AI.

Academics Question OpenAI: Controversy Over Problem-Solving Results and Data Usage

Mathematicians' dissatisfaction with OpenAI has a long history, and this controversy centers on two main issues: whether AI-generated mathematical answers have genuine research value and whether commercial companies have the right to use academic data and research results.

In October of this year, OpenAI announced that its model had solved several long-standing mathematical problems, but this news did not receive universal acclaim in the mathematics community. Some researchers believe that the answers released by OpenAI lack sufficient academic value and that human mathematicians may need to spend weeks determining whether the derivation process is rigorous and whether it truly solves the problem.

Caltech mathematics PhD student and outspoken anti-AI Substack blogger Tasmin Chu referred to these answers as "garbage." She believes that OpenAI's actions resemble leveraging research results in the mathematics field to create momentum for itself rather than genuinely advancing mathematical research.

The issue of data usage has further exacerbated tensions between the two sides. Previously, two mathematicians accused OpenAI of using their chat records without authorization to assist in solving the famous Navier-Stokes problem. This incident has heightened mathematicians' concerns that their interactions with AI systems may be used for commercial model training or research without permission.

Chu views the initiative of mathematicians to develop their own AI systems as part of the struggle for "ownership of the means of production." However, she also acknowledges that it remains to be seen how this trend will ultimately develop.

Bypassing Commercial Companies: Mathematicians Begin Building Specialized Models

In the face of the dominance of commercial AI companies, Gukov has chosen to start with model development. In a Caltech laboratory, he leads a small group of students in designing and training open-source AI models aimed at mathematical research. According to him, these models have already solved some of the mathematical problems that OpenAI has tackled.

However, the academic community's self-built models still face significant capability limitations. Gukov likened them to a Ferrari: excellent performance on specific tasks but difficult to meet the needs of a broad user base.

Currently, these models are mostly optimized for a specific type of mathematical problem, and their capabilities become significantly limited when asked to perform cross-domain reasoning. In contrast, models from commercial AI companies like Anthropic possess greater versatility and can handle mathematical problems across different disciplines. Gukov stated that the team is working on developing models with stronger general capabilities, but they are not yet ready.

Despite this, he remains optimistic about AI's involvement in mathematical research, believing that this field is full of exploratory potential. He described current AI research as akin to Columbus exploring new lands, which is exciting.

Mathematicians Have Not Reached Consensus: Terence Tao Promotes the Establishment of an Autonomous Platform

The initiative to build self-developed models does not imply that the mathematics community has formed a unified stance. There are still significant differences among scholars regarding whether AI should enter mathematical research.

Anti-AI scholars like Chu hope to maintain traditional research methods as much as possible. She stated that she still wishes to conduct mathematical research without relying on AI and believes that this path remains viable. Another group of younger mathematicians is more positive about AI, believing that new technologies may bring breakthroughs to mathematical research, while some see it as an opportunity to change existing research models.

Terence Tao is attempting to find a balance between the two. Recently, he showcased Open Math OS, a platform launched by his nonprofit organization at Caltech. This platform integrates cutting-edge open-source AI models, cloud computing resources, and collaboration tools, focusing on allowing mathematicians to decide how research data is used rather than completely handing over data control to commercial AI companies.

From specialized models to autonomous collaboration platforms, mathematicians are trying to establish a technological system different from that of commercial AI companies. Their core demands include not only enabling AI to better solve mathematical problems but also retaining control over research data, knowledge results, and their usage.

As AI's involvement in mathematical research continues to increase, the contradiction between the technological advantages of commercial models and the academic community's data autonomy will persist. Whether mathematicians can establish an independent research ecosystem capable of competing with large AI companies remains a key issue in this debate.

-- Price

--
--
--

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Any events, rewards, online promotions, or related information mentioned herein should not be considered a recommendation, solicitation, or invitation to purchase, sell, trade, or otherwise deal in any crypto assets. Crypto assets are highly volatile and may result in loss. The availability of WEEX services, products, and related events may vary by region. You are responsible for ensuring that your participation is in accordance with applicable local laws and regulations.

You may also like

iconiconiconiconiconiconiconiconicon
Customer Support:@weikecs
Business Cooperation:@weikecs
Quant Trading & MM:bd@weex.com
VIP Program:support@weex.com