The Vast Used Car Market: CarMax and Carvana Clash Over Americans' Car Buying Methods

By: finance.sina.com.cn|11/16/2026 10:05:26

The long-established giant CarMax is losing its luster as the emerging company Carvana rises rapidly; CarMax hopes to regain its dominance in the used car market with a new strategy and physical stores. CarMax has 260 stores, covering most of the United States.

This largest used car dealer in the U.S. is striving to maintain its industry leadership.

The used car industry has traditionally been filled with small family-run shops and aggressive sales tactics, often resulting in inconsistent vehicle quality. Now, both large companies are implementing a no-haggle pricing model to compete for industry dominance. One side is CarMax, the first national large-scale automotive retailer in the U.S. The other side is the digital newcomer Carvana, which is growing at a pace far exceeding CarMax and is favored by Wall Street capital.

In last month's earnings call, Carvana's CEO Ernie Garcia III sarcastically remarked that his company is just one step away from becoming the largest used car retailer in the U.S.

CarMax CEO Keith M. Anderson, however, is unfazed by such comparisons. In an interview, he stated, "This industry will not have just one winner and one loser. For many years to come, we will remain among the top retailers in the U.S. used car industry." CarMax CEO Keith M. Anderson

The competition between the two companies is part of a broader debate about the future model of car buying: as we enter the online era, will mobile apps become the primary channel for purchasing cars? Or do consumers still prefer to visit physical stores and experience the vehicles in person before spending tens of thousands of dollars?

CarMax bets on the latter. The company has 260 physical stores covering most of the U.S. while also engaging in pure online sales. Currently, the company is advancing transformation projects to align more closely with the native online company Carvana; Carvana users can select cars, arrange loans, and schedule vehicle delivery through their phones or computers.

Jeff Lick, an analyst at investment bank Stephens, stated that it is wise for Anderson to learn from competitors. "Great leaders do not cling to good ideas. If a competitor has made an innovative improvement that surpasses yours, just adopt it directly."

Amidst intensifying competition, more consumers are turning to used cars. The average price of new cars has soared to about $50,000, and insurance and maintenance costs have also risen significantly. The number of new car buyers in the U.S. has decreased by about 1 million compared to pre-pandemic levels, and this decline is not expected to rebound in the short term.

According to data from Cox Automotive Consulting, the annual retail sales volume of used cars in the U.S. is about 20 million units, with a market size of approximately $550 billion. The combined market share of CarMax and Carvana is still less than 10%, but both plan to capture more market share in the future.

With its extensive network of physical stores, CarMax believes it has an advantage: meeting consumers' needs for test drives and face-to-face interactions with sales consultants. However, investors believe the company has fallen behind in technology.

Due to years of declining sales, CarMax parted ways with former CEO Bill Nash in 2025. As of February 28, 2022, CarMax's vehicle sales peaked at 924,000 units; two years later, sales fell to 766,000 units. Over the past year, the company has conducted three rounds of layoffs.

Now, Anderson, who has no experience in the automotive industry and comes from the hotel sector, is tasked with leading CarMax to turn around its fortunes. His hiring was largely based on his past achievements in helping InterContinental Hotels Group (which includes brands like Holiday Inn, Kimpton, and InterContinental) strengthen its digital capabilities.

Anderson told investors that his strategy is to "iteratively improve CarMax rather than completely revolutionize it." CarMax plans to optimize the online car buying experience, but Anderson stated that they will not emulate Carvana by transforming into a purely online sales model.

"Even if consumers claim to prefer digital, in reality, the vast majority still want to visit stores for test drives," Anderson said. Carvana users primarily experience car buying by purchasing vehicles and relying on a 7-day return policy to test the cars. The nationwide "car vending machine" towers are only used for delivering online-ordered vehicles and do not provide car viewing or selection services.

However, on many detailed levels, Anderson is pushing CarMax to align more closely with Carvana. He is fully promoting the digitization of backend operations, aiming to reduce costs while providing lower prices without eroding profits.

In terms of refurbishing acquired used cars, Carvana has dozens of independent sites that use a factory assembly line model to prepare vehicles. In contrast, CarMax has primarily relied on retail store repair stations to refurbish vehicles for sale, still using a significant amount of paper forms and documents in repair operations.

To expedite the preparation process, CarMax plans to rely on computer software to determine which repairs are needed and which parts to order; Carvana has already been using self-developed software to complete this process since 2023. CarMax will begin establishing independent vehicle preparation centers in 2024, and Anderson plans to build more similar facilities.

Carvana employs an axle-radial logistics network that allows for low-cost vehicle distribution across the U.S. Anderson hopes to transform CarMax's decentralized store network to align with this model, increasing the proportion of centralized vehicle transportation.

CarMax also plans to earn more profits by expanding its self-operated auto finance business, focusing on customers with moderate credit scores. CarMax admits that issuing loans to more customers with average credit qualifications will suppress profits in the short term but will yield returns in the long run.

In contrast, 85% of Carvana's sales orders are financed by its own services, covering all credit levels, and then quickly bundling these loans to sell to banks and investors for profit.

Doug Hall, a 56-year-old lawyer, has bought two cars from CarMax. He appreciates the rich inventory at the CarMax main store near his home in Charlotte, North Carolina. Hall once sold a car to Carvana, but even with Carvana's generous return policy, he remains skeptical about ordering without seeing the actual vehicle. He once saw an almost perfect Audi displayed online at a local dealer, but when he visited the store, he found the interior reeked of marijuana.

"When buying a car, especially a used one, I must see it in person and drive it before making a decision," he said.

-- Price

--
--
--

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Any events, rewards, online promotions, or related information mentioned herein should not be considered a recommendation, solicitation, or invitation to purchase, sell, trade, or otherwise deal in any crypto assets. Crypto assets are highly volatile and may result in loss. The availability of WEEX services, products, and related events may vary by region. You are responsible for ensuring that your participation is in accordance with applicable local laws and regulations.

You may also like

iconiconiconiconiconiconiconiconicon
Customer Support:@weikecs
Business Cooperation:@weikecs
Quant Trading & MM:bd@weex.com
VIP Program:support@weex.com